Analysis: Clients of crypto lender Celsius face long wait over fate of their funds
By Hannah Lang, Elizabeth Howcroft and Tom Wilson
author
Reuterscontributor
Illustration shows Celsius logo and representation of cryptocurrencies

By Hannah Lang, Elizabeth Howcroft and Tom Wilson

WASHINGTON/LONDON (Reuters) – Customers of crypto lender Celsius face a long and anxious wait to know how, when and even if they will get their money back after the company filed for bankruptcy, becoming one of the biggest victims of the collapse in crypto markets this year.

Citing extreme market conditions, Celsius froze withdrawals in June in a move that reverberated through the crypto world and beyond, spurring a $300 billion selloff in digital assets and leaving legions of retail investors cut off from their savings.

Celsius Network, which is based in the U.S. state of New Jersey, revealed a gaping $1.2 billion hole in its balance sheet when it filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in New York this week.

Customers should now buckle up for a bumpy ride as they await some clarity over the fate of their money, six lawyers specialising in bankruptcies, restructuring or crypto told Reuters.

With scant precedent for bankruptcies at large crypto companies, the prospect of multiple lawsuits against Celsius, as well as the high complexity of any restructuring, the Chapter 11 process is likely to be slow, the lawyers said.

“This could last for years,” said Daniel Gwen at Ropes & Grey law firm in New York. “It’s highly likely there’s going to be a lot of litigation.”

Celsius did not reply to requests for comment.

Crypto lenders boomed during the pandemic, attracting retail customers with double-digit rates rarely offered by traditional banks, in return for their crypto asset deposits.

On the flip side, institutional investors such as hedge funds paid lenders higher rates to borrow the coins, leaving firms such as Celsius to profit from the difference. Lenders also invested in riskier, so-called decentralised finance markets.

‘THREE-DIMENSIONAL CHESS’

When crypto markets slumped this year as surging inflation rates sparked a flight to safer assets and two major tokens – terraUSD and luna – failed, the riskier bets by lenders on wholesale crypto markets turned soured.

U.S. crypto lender Voyager Digital filed for bankruptcy this month too after suspending withdrawals and deposits, while smaller Singapore lender Vauld and Hong Kong-based Babel Finance have also frozen withdrawals.

Chapter 11 bankruptcies allow companies to prepare turnaround plans while remaining operational.

While major crypto firms have failed before, most notably the Japanese exchange Mt. Gox in 2014, there is little precedent for the treatment of customers at stricken crypto lenders, the lawyers said.

“It is, at best, unknown how the bankruptcy code and bankruptcy courts will be treating cryptocurrency companies,” said James Van Horn, partner at Barnes & Thornburg in Washington.

Creditor committees formed as part of bankruptcy proceedings will likely seek to shape any reorganisation plan decided by Celsius, three lawyers said. Creditors can also make claims against the company even as it goes through the process.

“It’s probably going to take, given the complexity, six months, at a minimum just to develop a plan to come out of bankruptcy,” said Stephen Gannon, partner at Davis Wright Tremaine. “This is going to be three-dimensional chess.”

In general, Chapter 11 bankruptcies prioritise repayments to secured creditors, then unsecured creditors, and then equity holders.

“(Unsecured creditors) have no earmarked rights to any funds or anything, everything’s been commingled,” Van Horn said. “Sometimes it’s a very small amount that unsecured creditors get.”

‘LAST ON THE LIST’

Celsius said in court filings this week that it had more than 100,000 creditors.

As of July 13, it had some 23,000 outstanding loans to retail borrowers worth $411 million, backed by crypto collateral worth $766 million, it said in a filing on Thursday.

While Celsius listed its largest 50 creditors, it made no mention of the order in which they would be repaid and many of its 1.7 million clients are individual investors.

One of them is Martin Jabou, 27, who lives in Hamilton, Canada. He put crypto assets worth about $45,000 into Celsius, though they are now worth less than half of that.

“I think we’re going to be last on the list,” he said of any repayments from the bankruptcy. “I don’t know how to afford rent or car payments, especially with the other debts that I have.”

Crypto lenders such as Celsius acted in a similar way to banks. But unlike for mainstream lenders, there is no safety net for people such as Jabou when crypto platforms fail.

At U.S. banks, deposits of up to $250,000 are insured by a federal body. Broker-dealer clients are insured for up to $500,000 in securities and cash by a separate body.

Similar deposit protection schemes exist in the European Union and Britain.

While it is not clear how Celsius will classify its clients, it did warn customers it may treat them as unsecured creditors – and customers are likely to litigate over such a status, said Max Dilendorf, a lawyer in New York specialising in crypto.

“It will be a one-of-a-kind case to see why customers should be classified as unsecured creditors,” he said.

(Reporting by Tom Wilson and Elizabeth Howcroft in London and Hannah Lang in Washington; Editing by David Clarke)

About the Author

Reuters, part of Thomson Reuters, is the largest international multimedia news provider in the world with a daily audience of more than one billion. Through Thomson Reuters desktops, the world's media organizations, and Reuters.com and Reuters TV, Reuters provides trusted business, financial, and national news to professionals and consumers alike.

Full Bio
Top Stories
Solana (SOL) Price Analysis – Bullish Momentum Persists Despite Recent Pullback
Solana (SOL) Price Analysis – Bullish Momentum Persists Despite Recent Pullback

Solana (SOL) has been on a rollercoaster ride over the past few months, with the cryptocurrency experiencing significant volatility and price swings. Starting with the 120-day period from November 27th, 2023 to March 25th, 2024, SOL kicked off at $55.05 and embarked on a steady climb, reaching a local high of $120.90 on December 25th. […]

Mar 25, 2024
Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis – Bullish Long-Term Trend Faces Short-Term Volatility
Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis – Bullish Long-Term Trend Faces Short-Term Volatility

Ethereum (ETH) has been on a rollercoaster ride over the past few months, with the cryptocurrency experiencing significant volatility across different time frames. Looking at the 120-day chart, we can see that ETH has been in a strong uptrend since late November 2023, with the price more than doubling from $2,027.58 to a high of […]

Mar 25, 2024
Bitcoin (BTC) Price Analysis – Bullish Momentum Waning After Strong Rally, Key Support Levels to Watch
Bitcoin (BTC) Price Analysis – Bullish Momentum Waning After Strong Rally, Key Support Levels to Watch

Bitcoin’s price action over the last 120 days has been a rollercoaster ride for investors. Starting around $37,000 in late November 2023, the price rallied strongly, nearly doubling to reach a high around $73,000 in early February 2024. However, after this impressive run, the price began to lose steam, retracing to around $50,000 by late […]

Mar 25, 2024
Solana (SOL) Price Analysis – A Rollercoaster Ride Through Resistance and Support Levels
Solana (SOL) Price Analysis – A Rollercoaster Ride Through Resistance and Support Levels

In the last few months, Solana (SOL) has demonstrated a volatile yet upward trajectory, breaking through resistance levels and occasionally falling back to test support within designated ranges. Notably, the asset showcased significant price movements and trading volumes, indicating strong buying and selling pressures at various points. The recent analysis reveals a bullish momentum, with […]

Feb 29, 2024
Ripple (XRP) Price Analysis – Navigating Through Volatility with Resilience
Ripple (XRP) Price Analysis – Navigating Through Volatility with Resilience

In the ever-evolving landscape of cryptocurrency markets, Ripple (XRP) has showcased a remarkable journey of resilience amidst volatility. Over the last 120 days, Ripple’s price has navigated through significant fluctuations, breaking above resistance levels and dipping below support levels, with trading volumes closely mirroring these pivotal movements. The recent analysis reveals a dynamic interplay between […]

Feb 29, 2024
Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis – Surging Past Key Resistance Levels
Ethereum (ETH) Price Analysis – Surging Past Key Resistance Levels

In a remarkable journey over the last 120 days, Ethereum has showcased a bullish trend, breaking through multiple resistance levels with significant volume spikes. The recent analysis reveals Ethereum’s dynamic price movements, from struggling below the green range to soaring above the orange range, marking a peak at $3374.17. This upward trajectory is supported by […]

Feb 29, 2024
Bitcoin (BTC) Price Analysis – Surging to New Heights with Unstoppable Momentum
Bitcoin (BTC) Price Analysis – Surging to New Heights with Unstoppable Momentum

in the latest price analysis, Bitcoin (BTC) has shown an impressive surge, breaking through multiple resistance levels with significant trading volumes backing each move. Starting from a modest $35,421.4 in November 2023, BTC has climbed to a staggering $63,690.1 by February 2024. This journey was marked by a series of bullish breakouts, each supported by […]

Feb 29, 2024
Bitcoin’s Spectacular Journey: Volatility and Resilience
Bitcoin’s Spectacular Journey: Volatility and Resilience

Over the past 120 days, Bitcoin has shown remarkable volatility and resilience, climbing from $34,000 to over $52,000, supported by bullish moving averages.

Feb 26, 2024
Natural Gas and Oil Analysis: NG Rallies Over 5%; Stronger Dollar Weighs on Oil
Natural Gas and Oil Analysis: NG Rallies Over 5%; Stronger Dollar Weighs on Oil

Key Points: Strengthened dollar and high U.S. inflation fears prompt oil price decline, complicating rate cut expectations. Natural Gas surges 5.65% to $1.7760, bullish above pivot point $1.7333, with resistance up to $1.9291. UK Oil dips to $81.30, bearish below pivot $81.93, despite potential support at $80.67 and lower. In this article: Natural Gas -0.40% […]

Feb 26, 2024
Gold May Hit New Highs In 2024
Gold May Hit New Highs In 2024

Gold managed to stay above the key $2000 level despite rising Treasury yields.

Feb 26, 2024
DAX Index Forecast: 17,500 in the Hands of ECB President Lagarde
DAX Index Forecast: 17,500 in the Hands of ECB President Lagarde

Economic indicators from Germany signaled a worsening economic backdrop.

Feb 26, 2024
The Market News Today: TSMC Diversifies, Opens First Japan Chip Factory
The Market News Today: TSMC Diversifies, Opens First Japan Chip Factory

Samsung unveils Galaxy Ring with health-tracking features, enters smart ring market.

Feb 26, 2024
Cryptoverse: Bitcoin miners escape the bear trap
Cryptoverse: Bitcoin miners escape the bear trap

By Medha Singh and Lisa Pauline Mattackal

Jul 16, 2023
Dollar gains after strong New York factory survey
Dollar gains after strong New York factory survey

By Harry Robertson and Rae Wee LONDON/SINGAPORE (Reuters) – The dollar climbed to a one-month high against Japan’s yen on Monday as traders eyed up another interest rate hike from the Federal Reserve, while the Bank of Japan stuck to its easy money policies.

Apr 17, 2023
SEC chair to defend rulemaking, enforcement record before Congress
SEC chair to defend rulemaking, enforcement record before Congress

By Chris Prentice and John McCrank NEW YORK (Reuters) – The head of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) plans to defend its rulemaking and policing of market misconduct at a Tuesday hearing led by Republican lawmakers who have accused it of overstepping its authority.

Apr 17, 2023
Largest Contentful Paint